Juvenile Instructor » Call for Submissions: JWHA Article/Book Awards
 


Call for Submissions: JWHA Article/Book Awards

By: admin - February 16, 2013

JWHA Best Article Award Criteria

Award Criteria

Judges will select the best articles (privileging works that are most relevant to Community of Christ history or theology, regardless of the time period they encompass) based on the following criteria:

Articles published in the calendar year prior to the award.

Clear research methodology with a knowledgeable approach to the subject material, a clearly stated thesis, and well-developed and well-supported argumentation with a balanced approach, particularly on points of controversy.

Factual and accurate documentation with corroborating source material—including an appropriate familiarity and use of primary and secondary sources—and care to position the argument in the broader historical context, religious studies, and national/international history where relevant (i.e. footnotes, endnotes, appendices, bibliography, index).

Well written (clear, concise, readable) with appropriate attention to organization, transitional elements, and interesting and specific supporting details.

Best Historical

Deals with an event or a person/group of persons of historical interest in shedding light on some aspect of the larger Community of Christ/Restoration movement or with an episode that has either been under-interpreted or, in an important respect, misinterpreted in the context of the larger Community of Christ/Restoration movement. In addition, papers are considered that analyze the history of ideas shaping community or culture, objects that represent a unique aspect of culture, or places, showing the sacred (or non-sacred) element of geography in history. Gives appropriate attention and weight to factors both in and out of the movement that provided a shaping direction. We encourage particular attention to understudied groups or individuals such as often-overlooked social classes, women, children, ethnic groups, and minorities. Should make every effort to find and use archival material (including, but not limited to personal papers, institutional papers, photographs, sound recordings) but, in their absence, triangulate carefully from secondary sources and other primary sources to re-create probable motives, goals, and positions. Also includes such aspects of social history as material culture, broader Mormon studies, institutional history, lived religion, or change over time in any of these areas.

Best Theological

As a religious body with an important spiritual history, works studying the theological development of the Community of Christ/Restoration movement should follow trends in scholarship. Papers can address a concept, scriptural or revelatory interpretation, or social movement fueled by a particular scriptural or revelatory interpretation. In addition to a sound and thorough contextualization that includes origins (and possible origins) of the concept, the article needs to explore areas of strength and weakness as manifested by its adherents and opponents, its development over time, and its current status.

Review Process

A review committee of JWHA members will individually evaluate the articles based on the above criteria. The committee gladly accepts nominations of works meeting the above criteria. Please submit the author and title of the work before the deadline date of June 30. Submissions should be e-mailed to mormonhistorygirl@hotmail.com.

Awards

Kofford Best Historical Article Award             $250

Kofford Best Theological Article Award          $250

_____________________________________________

JWHA Best Book Award Criteria

Award Criteria

Judges will select the best books (privileging works that are most relevant to Community of Christ history, regardless of the time period they encompass) based on the following criteria:

Books published in the calendar year prior to the award.

Clear research methodology with a knowledgeable approach to the subject material, a clearly stated thesis, and well-developed and well-supported argumentation with a balanced approach, particularly on points of controversy.

Factual and accurate documentation with corroborating source material—including an appropriate familiarity and use of primary and secondary sources—and care to position the argument in the broader historical context, religious studies, and national/international history where relevant (i.e. footnotes, endnotes, appendices, bibliography, index).

Well written (clear, concise, readable) with appropriate attention to organization, transitional elements, and interesting and specific supporting details.

Best Documentary History

Documentary editing volumes will be considered based on scholarly standards of transcription, annotation, and document contextualization. The published document(s) should deal with topics of the restoration and particularly with Community of Christ History. Annotation, introductions, and other resource material should support the documents and be of the highest scholarly quality. Selection criteria should be clearly and logically followed in cases of collections of documents.

Best Biography

Books based on the life of a single individual or family will be considered for the best biography award. Though biographical works are largely about telling an individual’s life story, the JWHA awards committee encourages works that place the individual within the larger historical narrative, providing contextual information about the individual’s life. The same rigorous, scholarly standards looked for in other works will be sought after in biographies.

Best Anthology

Articles within anthologies, edited collections, or collections of essays will normally be considered on that article’s individual merit. However, the JWHA awards committee will consider entire volumes based on merit and academic standards. They will look for a logical thematic approach to the articles within the volume, in addition to historiographical contribution.

Review Process

A review committee of JWHA members will individually evaluate the books based on the above criteria. The committee gladly accepts nominations of works meeting the above criteria. Please submit the author and title of the work before the deadline date of June 30. Submissions should be e-mailed to mormonhistorygirl@hotmail.com.

Awards

Smith-Pettit Best Book Award                                        $1,000

Mormonabilia Best Biography Book Award                $500

Mormonabilia Best Anthology Book Award               $500

JWHA Best Documentary History Book Award                    $500

Share and enjoy:


No Comments

No comments yet.